Books aren’t written, they’re rewritten. Including your own. It is one of the hardest things to accept, especially after the seventh rewrite hasn’t quite done it. ~ Michael Crichton
Notes on giving feedback on WIP (work in progress)
- Start Positive
- End Positive
- address comments to the WIP and not the writer such as “I didn’t understand this sentence…” as opposed to “You need to…”
- it might help to begin with a summary of what you got from the piece, what you thought it was about
- tell the author what worked and why – point out strengths
- tell the author what didn’t work and why it didn’t work for you – make suggestions to strengthen the work – don’t just leave them hanging with “I didn’t like this.” or “This doesn’t work for me.”
- it’s important to know the difference between your own personal style of writing and preferences in terms of writing style and try to separate these from your critiques >if you are not familiar or comfortable with the genre or writing style then it may be best to not comment on the WIP but small editing elements like spelling and punctuation can still be offered
Take time and effort when giving feedback > read the piece in advance, make notes, offer suggestions, be supportive and encouraging.
Here is a helpful pdf on Creative Writing workshop critiquing from Fred Meijer Center for Writing & Michigan Authors.
The beautiful part of writing is that you don’t have to get it right the first time, unlike, say, a brain surgeon. ~ Robert Cormier